In March 2006, Cablevision Systems Corporation announced that it would be rolling out a new Remote-Storage Digital Video Recorder theory ("Rs-Dvr"), intended for use by its customers who did not have a digital video recorder in their homes, and would permit these customers to description programs on central servers located at Cablevision's facilities and play the programs back for viewing at home.
Cablevision is the owner and operator of cable television systems, primarily in the New York City metropolitan area and provides a wide variety of programs to its customers.
Hard Drive Storage Boxes
Cablevision did not procure permission from the copyright owners of the programs to be recorded, relying instead on the United States consummate Court decision in Sony Corp. V. Universal City Studios, Inc. Which permitted time-shifting straight through use of the now ubiquitous Vcrs by the recording of television programs for in-home, personal viewing.
Cablevision was sued by various television networks, movie studios and other creators of copyrighted entertainment programs in the United States District Court in the Southern District of New York. In a decision dated March 22, 2007, the Court rejected Cablevision's contentions. This decision, although dealing with video content, applies equally to photography.
The Court went to great lengths to review the technical aspects of how article is transmitted in cable television and the Dvr system. The gist of it is that many cable fellowships offer "set-top" warehouse Dvrs, which join the functions of a standard cable set-top box and a Dvr. This permits recording of digital programming directly onto a hard drive contained in the box. This in turn permits time shifting in a manner similar to Vcrs.
In this case, it was undisputed that the plaintiffs owned valid copyrights. Therefore, since Cablevision had previously agreed it would not assert a "fair use" defense, the only issue to be decided was either Cablevision was copying plaintiffs' copyrighted programs. The Court held that it was.
The Court determined that the Rs-Dvr theory was not a stand-alone motor that sits on top of a television. Instead, it was a complicated theory that involves an ongoing relationship in the middle of Cablevision and its customers, payment of monthly fees by the customers with ownership of the tool remaining with Cablevision, the use of numerous computer and other tool located in Cablevision's underground facilities, and the ongoing maintenance of the theory on a 24 hour/7 day per week basis by Cablevision personnel.
The Court concluded that Cablevision, and not its customers, would be the party which copied the article and therefore the party engaged in unauthorized reproductions and transmissions of plaintiffs' copyrighted programs.
Accordingly, the Court entered judgment permanently enjoining Cablevision from copying or lively in public performances of plaintiffs' copyrighted works in relationship with the Rs-Dvr theory without first obtaining valid licenses.
The Court's holding, recognizing the lasting strengthen of technology, did not hold the Rs-Dvr theory to be illegal. It only enjoined use of copyrighted material used without a license. Accordingly, properly licensed material, or material in the public domain, would not be affected.
The retention of the case clearly extends to still photography, either as part of video content, or as stand alone photographs. It is yet other instance of the courts properly extending the provisions of the Copyright Act to new and emerging technology in order to safe article providers.
Use Of Infringing Rs-Dvr principles Enjoined